My Photo
Name:
Location: San Francisco, California, United States

I am a 77 year old retired trial lawyer, and an active mediator/arbitrator who is also a baseball nut. In 2001 I attended the San Francisco Giants Fantasy Camp in Scottsdale. Since then, after eleven subsequent camps and a kidney transplant I am still attempting to play baseball with the young folks. My trials and tribulations in returning to the game, together with comments upon sports, the passing political scene and developments in the law, will, on an irregular basis, appear on this site A word of warning, I am a recovering Republican-a-holic who has been driven from my party by George W Bush and the Tea Party (which is making George Bush look good). You are invited to agree, disagree or just chime in with any comments.

Monday, August 21, 2006

Old Thoughts on Current Issues-Disclosure of Grand Jury Sources and the First Amendment

This is an old "Letter to the Editor" which is still current today:

Sent: Tuesday, October 12, 2004 10:02 AMTo: 'letters@sfchronicle.com'Subject: The First Amendment

Your attack upon the Justice Department for issuing subpoenas to journalists in the Plame investigation is misplaced. (Editorial, October 12) I believe you will find that those subpoenas were issued not by the Justice Department but by a special prosecutor. You should have spent your space and time in attacking the Justice Department and examining your own conduct in connection with the inexcusable leaks from the grand jury in the Balco matter. As an attorney, who has had legitimate access to grand jury materials in other matters, I recognize that the attorneys and others working on a case have a sacred professional responsibility not to breach the secrecy of a grand jury. This is totally apart from the fact that such conduct can and should be prosecuted. It appears that the Justice Department (or an employee thereof) has leaked grand jury testimony in the Balco matter and in the process damaged the defendants in that case, as well as the reputations of countless, presumed to be innocent athletes. The justice department has sought to exploit the case for political purposes, in league with the drug testing nannies led by Dick Pound. The Chronicle should revaluate its conduct in participating, publishing and sensationalizing the leaking and dissemination of grand jury testimony. On the one hand, you withhold information about Kobie Bryant's accuser, while at the same time printing innuendo about the greatest player ever to play the game. The first amendment is not absolute, a grand jury is often a star chamber, and the constitution does not mandate the publication of hearsay and innuendo contained in grand jury transcripts. Your source or sources should be identified and prosecuted, the Balco prosecution which appears to be hopelessly compromised should be dismissed and you should evaluate your conduct in disseminating and capitalizing upon such unauthorized disclosures.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home