Another old letter to the Editor re Moral Values in Election Polling also timely today from one who is Older, Sadder and wiser, though without regrets, except for comments about leadership and character which need to be updated. Stay tuned.
Sent: Saturday, November 06, 2004 10:28 AMTo: 'letters@nytimes.com'Cc: 'dabrooks@nytimes.com'Subject: Political Capital and Moral Values
David Brooks ("The Values-Vote Myth," column, Nov. 6) almost gets it right. What is omitted is the probability that a substantial portion of the "moral value voters" were nothing more than anti-Kerry voters who understood the exit poll alternative related to character as opposed to issues. I am a fiscally conservative Republican who supports stem cell research, choice and domestic partnerships, yet, if faced with a closed end question providing the alternative of taxes, education, Iraq, terrorism, economy/jobs, moral values or health care as the basis for my vote, I would respond "moral values."
Voters answered this question in the context of wall to wall advertisements by the campaigns, the parties and 527s such as MoveOn.org and the Swift Boat Vets. It was a campaign of attack and smear accompanied by a drumbeat of hatred, negativism and fear mongering. Senator Kerry never presented a positive alternative. The campaign was "You know where I stand" as opposed to "I voted for before I voted against." In the context of the ads and the statements of the candidates, it is probable that a majority of voters determined that character matters. These voters undoubtedly believed that "moral values" related to the character of the candidate as opposed to any particular issue. If a centrist voter agreed with a candidate on some issues and not others or, if he or she didn't know what the Senator Kerry really believed, that voter could take the high road in responding to a pollster --"moral values".
Given this explanation of a flawed exit poll, the chicken little mentality of the far left and the claims of those clamoring for the appointment of a pro life Supreme Court justice are misplaced. There remains a vast center, both in the Democratic and Republican parties, who voted based upon character and the perceived abilities of the candidates. President Bush does have political capital based upon his leadership and character and he should spend that capital it in pursuit of his foreign and domestic policy. However, as will be demonstrated in response to his first Supreme Court appointment, it would be a mistake to assume that that capital is based upon the endorsement of the agenda of the religious right. The election results, and particularly the exit polls, provide no mandate on any particular issue including the application of a litmus test for the Supreme Court. One can only hope that the President will live up to the electorate's endorsement of his character and become a "uniter not a divider".